England football legend Gareth Southgate has found himself at the centre of a heated debate after voicing concerns that flying the St George’s flag could risk undermining national unity.
Speaking on BBC Breakfast, the former England manager reflected on the role football has played in uniting communities across the country.
“I worry about unity,” Southgate said. “I’ve seen what we did with the team to bring every community together.
I do think there’s more that bonds us than separates us. We should focus on that rather than what divides us.”
Social Media Erupts With Criticism
Southgate’s comments immediately drew sharp reactions online, with many questioning why a symbol of England would be seen as divisive.
One user on X wrote, “The Cross of St George is the flag of England—the country he represented.
How can that be divisive? Someone please explain his attitude.”
Another commented, “Oh do shove it Southgate… no one is interested in your opinion on flying a national flag.”
A History of Measured Commentary
Southgate stepped down as England manager in 2024 after eight years in charge, having led the team to two European Championship finals, a World Cup semi-final, and a quarter-final.
Known for his measured approach, he has since established himself as a thought leader, publishing Dear England: Lessons in Leadership.
However, suggesting that a national flag could create division has clearly stirred strong opinions, particularly as the St George’s flag has become a more visible presence in towns and cities this year.
Gary Neville Joins the Conversation
Southgate is not alone in his controversial stance. Former Manchester United defender Gary Neville also criticized the flag movement, describing it as the domain of “angry, middle-aged white men.”
Neville recounted seeing dozens of Union Jacks lining streets near Jewish communities in Manchester.
“I just kept thinking we’re all being turned on each other.
The division that’s being created is absolutely disgusting—mainly by people who know exactly what they’re doing,” he said.
Neville Faces Backlash and Protests
Neville’s comments have drawn fierce reactions, both online and in person.
At a recent Salford City match, far-right activists stormed the pitch carrying St George’s flags and chanting against Neville, accusing him of “treachery.”
Britain First claimed responsibility for the stunt, claiming to protest Neville’s criticism of nationalist symbols.
Despite the backlash, Neville has defended his position, emphasizing his patriotism. “I played for my country 85 times.
I love England, I love Manchester, and I’ve been building in this city for 15–20 years without ever seeing these flags. Why start now?”
Calls for a Neutral Approach
Both Southgate and Neville are urging a more neutral perspective when it comes to national symbols.
Neville highlighted that the Union Jack is being wielded in a negative, divisive way in certain contexts and stressed the importance of not being pulled to extremes politically.
“It’s time to check ourselves and come back to a neutral point,” he said.
“We don’t need to be pulled right and left—we need to focus on what unites us instead.”