It was a match filled with goals, tension, and divided opinions — and at the center of it all was Mamelodi Sundowns captain and goalkeeper Ronwen Williams.
As South Africa’s only club in the FIFA Club World Cup, all eyes were on the team.
But after a dramatic 4–3 defeat to Germany’s Borussia Dortmund, the spotlight turned sharply on Williams.
The game, played on Saturday, June 21, left South African fans feeling everything from frustrated to fiercely defensive, especially as Williams’ name started trending across social media.
One Costly Mistake That Shifted Momentum
Early in the game, one moment changed everything.
In what looked like a routine play, Williams attempted a back pass — but instead, it landed right at the feet of Dortmund’s Felix Nmecha, who happily turned the error into a goal.
That blunder became the turning point and arguably shifted the energy of the entire match.
Many supporters felt that one slip-up might have cost Sundowns the win, and the criticism came in thick and fast on X (formerly Twitter).
But just as quickly, others rushed to Williams’ defense, arguing that even the best keepers have off moments.
Fans Split Between Loyalty and Frustration
The backlash wasn’t entirely one-sided. Big names like DJ Mo Flava jumped into the conversation, reminding critics that “mistakes happen.”
When ESPN Africa asked fans whether Williams should stay in goal or be dropped, the replies reflected a nation torn.
Supporters like @phungula_BC tweeted, “All ball-playing keepers are bound to make mistakes… Ronwen is no exception,” while @LondzMkhumbuzi added, “Top goalkeepers bounce back stronger.”
But others weren’t so forgiving. @VictorVeeM criticized the idea of comparing Williams to Itumeleng Khune, and @KingBaloyii claimed the Sundowns captain had “reached the expiry date.”
Crucial Group Stage Match Against Fluminense Ahead
Despite the setback, the journey isn’t over yet.
Sundowns have one final chance to stay in the tournament, with a massive group-stage decider against Brazil’s Fluminense coming up on Tuesday, June 24.
Currently sitting third in Group F, Sundowns must win to secure a place in the Round of 16.
A draw might still get them through — but only if Ulsan Hyundai of South Korea somehow beats Dortmund and racks up the goal difference.
Will Williams Redeem Himself?
The big question now is: will Ronwen Williams silence the critics and redeem himself in Sundowns’ next match? The pressure is certainly on.
Fans across South Africa are holding their breath, hopeful that the team — and their captain — can deliver when it matters most.
Have your say: Do you think Williams deserves another shot, or should Sundowns switch things up?