In a story that has stirred deep emotions across Texas, a grieving father is challenging a school’s decision that he says disrespects his son’s memory.
After losing his teenage son in a brutal stabbing at a school sports event, Jeffrey Metcalf is now taking action against what he sees as a serious injustice.
His son, 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, was stabbed to death during a track meet in Frisco, Texas.
Now, the accused killer—18-year-old Karmelo Anthony—is still set to receive his high school diploma, and that’s something Austin’s father just can’t stay silent about.
A Heartbroken Father Files a Formal Complaint
Jeffrey Metcalf has filed an official grievance against Centennial High School, demanding accountability for their decision to let Anthony graduate.
Despite being charged with Austin’s killing, Anthony is reportedly still on track to earn his diploma, though he won’t be permitted to attend the graduation ceremony or walk the stage due to being under house arrest.
A representative for Anthony, Dominique Alexander, confirmed to DailyMail.com that Metcalf has taken his complaint to the Texas Education Agency (TEA)—one of the few ways he might be able to challenge the decision.
A Controversial Reversal and an Unfinished Expulsion
Originally, Frisco Independent School District had plans to expel Anthony, which would have automatically disqualified him from graduating.
But that changed dramatically after a high-profile press conference last month.
According to Alexander, the school reversed course and ultimately decided not to follow through with the expulsion.
Alexander stated, “They were literally trying to expel him—period.
But now, they’ve agreed to let him graduate, and we’re working out the details of an early graduation.”
The Tragic Attack That Shattered a Family
The attack happened on April 2 during a track meet at a stadium in Frisco.
Witnesses say Anthony allegedly pulled a knife on Austin, who was later found bleeding out in the arms of his twin brother. Anthony reportedly fled the scene but was quickly arrested.
He confessed to the stabbing, telling police, “I did it,” though he has since claimed it was in self-defense.
The harrowing image of Austin dying in his brother’s arms has haunted the local community—and beyond.
Public Outrage and a Flood of Donations
Despite the gravity of the charges, Anthony’s supporters have raised over $500,000 for his legal defense, igniting fierce debate online and in the community.
Many are outraged that someone accused of murder is not only free on bond but also being celebrated by some.
That outrage intensified when Anthony’s bond was slashed from $1 million to $250,000, allowing him to walk free.
During the bond hearing, his father argued that the family was financially strained since the arrest.
Luxury Living Despite Claims of Hardship
Adding fuel to the fire, DailyMail.com reported that the Anthony family was living in a $900,000 rental home in a gated community, despite claiming financial hardship.
This revelation didn’t sit well with their neighbors, many of whom expressed concerns about safety and trust.
One neighbor bluntly stated, “I don’t understand why he had a knife. It’s very scary.
Could he rob houses next? I don’t want him living nearby.”
Others agreed it would be best for the family to leave the neighborhood entirely, noting that tensions had reached a breaking point.
Anthony Relocates Amid Safety Concerns
Eventually, Anthony did move out, claiming that his location had been leaked online, putting his safety at risk.
His current whereabouts remain undisclosed, but the controversy surrounding his case—and the question of whether justice is being served—continues to spark heated conversation.
What Comes Next?
As graduation ceremonies approach, the spotlight remains on Frisco ISD, the Texas Education Agency, and the broader community grappling with grief, anger, and questions of fairness.
For Jeffrey Metcalf, the fight is far from over.
He’s seeking answers, accountability, and above all, justice for his son Austin—a young life taken far too soon.